This Month's MagazineDining and SpiritsArts and EntertainmentTravel and LeisureHome and Real EstateHealth and WellnessShopping & FashionEvents and PicsElegant Wedding Magazine

Bookmark and share

Issue Date: September 2008

First Impressions

Andy Netzel, photography by Billy Delfs
When I forget my newspaper or magazine on the bus or Rapid, I often end up staring at the people traveling with me or those in the nearby cars. Sometimes I make up little stories about them.

What's YOUR first impression?
We're keeping this idea going and you can be part of the experiment. Visit our First Impressions blog to give us your take on the photos posted there. We'll add new photos on a regular basis and periodically provide you information about the individuals we feature, so you can see how close (or way off) you were. Feeling brave, you can upload your own photo, too. JOIN IN >>
The woman with crooked lipstick, heavy perfume and dyed-red hair appears to be a lonely widow. She’d prefer to stay home, but gets on the bus every day because she hasn’t saved enough for retirement.

She stares back. I wonder what she thinks of me.

So, with a nod to an art piece by Lenka Clayton and James Price, I put on a social experiment of sorts with the help of photographer Billy Delfs, who set up lights and a background on Public Square and in the Warehouse District.

For nine hours, we talked to anyone who passed by or asked to be photographed. But we also wanted to capture a representative sample of who makes up downtown on a given day — a range of young and old, male and female, affluent-looking and those who appeared to be a little more rough around the edges.

We wanted a mix of races. We wanted to make sure we talked to someone with a dog and someone with a beer. We wanted someone yakking on their cell phone. We wanted locals and tourists. We photographed and interviewed about twice as many people than appear in this story.

We told people that we’d take their picture and ask them their first impression of someone else, but others would scrutinize them and give their own first impressions. It was shocking how many eager participants there were. Only two people in that nine-hour span walked away after hearing the ground rules.

The quotes often reveal as much about the person responding as those being scrutinized. They say a lot about who we are in Northeast Ohio.

Play along. We saved some basic information about each person photographed for the end, so you can see how close your assumptions are. Just look at the corresponding letters.

Roll your cursor over each small photo to see each person’s comment. The red letters indicate people who both made a comment and were later commented on.
First impression - a First impression - c
  First impression - b First impression - d

First impression - a

First impression - e  First impression - f

First impression - g  First impression - h

First impression - i  First impression - j

First impression - g First impression - k
First impression - l

  First impression - f

First impression - m
First impression - n

First impression - l

First impression - o

First impression - p

First impression - q

  First impression - k


First impression - r

First impression - s

First impression - t_sm

First impression - n

First impression - u

First impression - v

First impression - w

  First impression - t

First impression - x
First impression - y

First impression - q

First impression - z
First impression - aa

First impression - z We asked this man to look at his own photo a week later: “For some people, the idea of appearance isn’t important. But it’s really the way most people make their first impressions. I try to appear the way I would like the world to perceive me. It’s easy to look at pictures and make impressions, then when you look at yourself it’s shocking. It’s like, ‘This is what everyone else sees.’ Am I really that skinny? If I looked at my picture, I would think this person probably readsDetails magazine, watches Bravo on television, and that’s true even if I hate to admit it. I’m glad that I was talking on the phone and didn’t have to pose. Plus, it is hiding my bald spot.”
We asked our participants if they would provide some basic information about themselves: A. Denice Hunt, Westlake. Unemployed. Former waitress, insists Cleveland Magazine should rate The Claddagh Irish Pub at Legacy Village best restaurant in next month’s “Best of” issue; B. Franklin Canning, Columbia, S.C., here on business; C. Lisa Bridget, 35, Cleveland, assistant social worker; D. Alphonso Tidwell, 46, Cleveland, bounty hunter; E. Michael Clark, 50, Cleveland, sales supervisor; F. Jodi Dudek, 27, Cleveland, graphic designer; G. Arthur Owens, 28, hip-hop and R&B artist working full time at Arby’s until his big break; H. Omar Esquilin, 33, Cleveland, home remodeler who emigrated from Puerto Rico; I. Rob Rob,57, East Cleveland, postal worker, showed his ID to prove he wasn’t lying about his unusual name; J. Elena Muscutariu and Pia Kasseckert, 65 and 5 respectively, retired pharmacy worker from Germany living in Cleveland and vacationing grandchild who is still learning English; K. Lindsey Bower, 26, Cleveland, graphic designer who says she may look irritated because she got out of a 6-year relationship the day before being photographed; L. Mai-Kim Dang, 28, Cleveland, film student at Cleveland State who asked our photographer for his phone number. He hopes she calls; M. Lee Polk, 26, Cleveland, cook, was wearing a T-shirt that, fittingly, said: “Unless you wuz me, how can you judge me?”; N. Sean Gallagher, 12, Cedar Rapids, Iowa, in town to see the AST Dew Tour of extreme sports; O. Garrick Liscomb, 39, University Heights, I.T. professional; P. Tonnie Alliance, Solon, regional director of distinguished events for the American Cancer Society; Q. George Woods, 42, Cleveland, works at the Animal Protective League and as a security guard. He knows he looks tough but he’s really a teddy bear; R. Lamonte Coulter, 43, Cleveland, chef for Jones Day, but he should be a stand-up comic with the way he had us cracking up; S. Lisa Brozewicz and Lexi, 22 and five months respectively, financial analyst and vizsla respectively; T. Charles Moss, 29, Lakewood, accountant who was happy to participate until we asked him not to finish his beer until we finished photographing him; U. Doug Martin, 23, Cleveland, bike messenger; V. Kevin Brooks, 32, Shaker Heights, program coordinator and founder of Keeping Everyone Young Successful; W. Georgene Gibson, 32, server at XO Prime Steaks; X. Jeremy Hank, 32, Rocky River, waiter; Y. Linda Henderson, 49, Akron, surgical technician; Z. John Plymak, 40, Lakewood, graphic designer who stood talking on his phone not knowing why we were taking his picture until he finished his phone call; AA. Jessica Pagan, 27, Cleveland, server.
Monday, August 25, 2008 5:08:55 PM by Ian Hoffman
This is a very interesting socilogical experiment. The information at the end was good to get to check people's first impressions, and was written in a funny was too boot.
Monday, August 25, 2008 5:10:16 PM by Ian Hoffman
Oops, that's "written in a funny way to boot."
Tuesday, August 26, 2008 10:36:26 AM by Anonymous
I know "T"...and he is not an Accountant.
Tuesday, August 26, 2008 1:51:19 PM by Anonymous
I know "T" as well...and "Y" pretty much hit the nail on the head.
Tuesday, August 26, 2008 5:07:33 PM by "T"
thats true im IN acountin' not and accountant in low on the totem pole ....but i mumble !!!southern upbringing we all can t speak clearly .... LOL .and heck ya ....the beer was getting warm!!! who wouldnt get "upset" about that ....These guys were awesome. and a very neat experiment post ur pics and see what happens ..........p.s. i soooo need to get some sun too!!! check out the glowing skin on me. "T"
Wednesday, August 27, 2008 12:51:05 PM by D115
Hey "T" that's gonna have to be your new nickname! LOL... I'm mad that I wasn't picked for this! I wish I hadn't finished my beer!! I am gonna upload my pic on here for comments! :-)
Saturday, August 30, 2008 12:58:13 AM by Mai-Kim
I can't believe Tonnie thought that I was here on a visa LOL.
My mom and grandmother are from Cleveland, Ohio, and my great grandmother is from Atlanta, Georgia :-) This was such a fun experiment, I think the blog will have less bias though because you'll be more comfortable to answer without fear of appearing in a negative way !

Wednesday, September 03, 2008 4:15:04 PM by Anonymous
Andy...nice work, your Mom talks about you all the time.
I used to do sets at Fine Arts....your Mom works for my dad....
Thursday, September 11, 2008 1:36:50 PM by Anonymous
I was wondering if it would be possible to get "W"'s telephone number.
Tuesday, September 23, 2008 10:22:51 AM by Anonymous
i know D and he is not a bounty hunter
Tuesday, September 23, 2008 10:45:31 AM by anonymous
D is not a bounty hunter....he sells fruit snacks. Definitely gay.
Saturday, October 04, 2008 10:00:03 PM by Anonymous
F is quite cute. I would venture that she rides bikes often as is health conscious. Also has a cat and dog.
Sunday, October 05, 2008 3:48:55 PM by Chris L
D is mos def not a bounty hunter. I saw him downtown last Friday with a plastic box. He sales fruit snacks and passes out fliers. L is pretty though.
Monday, March 23, 2009 1:36:19 PM by Maisha A L Dang
I think this is a great experiement. People should not make assuptions on first glances of a person. Speak up and get to know a stranger.
Friday, March 05, 2010 3:05:58 PM by Anonymous
D is a bounty but still is gay

Comments. All comments must be approved by our editorial staff.
Choose an identity
Other Anonymous
All of these fields are optional.
CAPTCHA Validation
Retype the code from the picture
CAPTCHA Code Image
Speak the code Change the code

Home | Subscribe | Archives | Advertise | Newsstands | Contact Us | Jobs | Legal
© Cleveland Magazine 2014 | P: (216) 771-2833 | F: (216) 781-6318 | 1422 Euclid Ave. Suite 730 Cleveland, Ohio 44115
This site is a member of the City & Regional Magazine Association