Best Restaurants in North Olmsted and Olmsted Falls: Dining Guide

The Big Egg

Why we love it: With the longtime Downtown location now closed, this North Olmsted outpost carries on a Cleveland diner tradition that dates back decades. Open from morning through early evening, the menu goes beyond breakfast staples, making it an easy stop any time of day. Inside, the classic diner vibe holds strong with a small counter, plenty of seating and a laid-back atmosphere. Try this: The Monte Cristo ($14.99) is a well-rounded bite, stacking ham, turkey, eggs and Swiss cheese between two slices of French toast, served with a side of hash browns. 24111 Lorain Road, North Olmsted, 440-455-9207, bigeggrestaurant.com

Black Seed Cafe

Why we love it: Tucked away in a suburban shopping plaza, this cafe serves shawarma, Middle Eastern snacks and iced coffee drinks in a relaxed setting. Moody tones and wood paneling set a warm tone, anchored by a striking hand-painted mural. Try this: The zaatar and cheese pie ($3) is earthy and aromatic, with savory herbal notes, toasted nuttiness and a bright, lemony tang that lingers on the palate. 28879 Lorain Road, North Olmsted, 440-455-1319, instagram.com/blackseedcafecle

Cilantro Taqueria

Why we love it: If you’re looking for authentic Mexican street food, Cilantro Taqueria has become a go-to for bold, craveable flavor. Now with six locations, the quick-service spot has steadily won over Northeast Ohio, earning a place on Cleveland Magazine’s Best Restaurants list in 2023. Try this: The elote ($4.75) is a must, charred corn coated in creamy, savory goodness. Don’t skip the birria tacos with consomme ($14), three cheese-stuffed beef cheek tacos served with a rich, dunkable broth that delivers on every bite. 24950 Lorain Road, North Olmsted, 440-496-7971, cilantrotaqueria.com

Clementine’s Victorian Restaurant

Why we love it: This charming, old-timey tea house feels tailor-made for a leisurely girls’ lunch or a special afternoon out. The building adds to the appeal, once an old stable and now thoughtfully renovated with both main-floor and upstairs dining. Inside, white wood paneling, wooden chairs with soft green cushions and tea served properly by the pot set a cozy scene. The menu highlights daily specials alongside an extensive list of more than 20 teas and a bakery case filled fresh each morning. Try this: Clementine’s Chicken Salad ($12.99) is a unanimous favorite, served on French bread with a choice of macaroni salad or kettle chips. 8092 Columbia Road, Olmsted Falls, 440-235-1223, clementinesrestaurant.getbento.com

Danny Boy’s Pizza

Why we love it: One of the largest locations in the Danny Boy’s lineup, this spot leans hard into nostalgia and family-friendly fun. Classic black-and-red booths, checkered lamps and walls packed with vintage signs, records and memorabilia give the space a lively, throwback feel. With a full bar, plenty of seating and the recent return of board games back in rotation, it’s a natural fit for groups looking to settle in and stay awhile. Try this: The Honey Bee pizza ($12–$27.75) hits the sweet-and-savory sweet spot, layering homemade sauce, a five-cheese blend, pepperoni, bacon, jalapeno and ricotta, finished with a drizzle of honey on a traditional crust. 24129 Lorain Road, North Olmsted, 440-360-7800, dannyboyspizza.com

Fat Head’s Brewery & Saloon

Why we love it: This flagship brewpub helped put Fat Head’s on the map and remains a go-to for craft beer lovers and casual diners alike, with a laid-back pub vibe that works for lunch, dinner or catching a game. The massive space features a sprawling dining room anchored by an impressively long, energetic bar, with brewing operations on full display. Try this: The Southside Slopes Headwich ($17) lives up to its name, stacking chargrilled kielbasa with sauteed pierogi and onions, melted American cheese and a kick of horseradish sauce, all served alongside a hearty portion of fries. 24581 Lorain Road, North Olmsted, 440-801-1001, fatheads.com/north-olmsted 

Fire and Dough Bakery

Why we love it: This Middle Eastern bakery and kitchen brings regional flavors to the forefront, pairing freshly baked breads and manakish with pizzas that layer cultural spices, herbs and unlikely toppings. The space feels grounded and welcoming, with cool-toned brick, arched details and greenery that nod to tradition. Open from morning through late evening, the menu moves easily from breakfast favorites to hearty plates and shareable pizzas. Try this: The cheeseburger ($10.99) wraps seasoned beef, sauteed mushrooms and onions with melted cheese inside house-made dough for a rich, savory bite you don’t want to miss. 26721 Brookpark Extension, North Olmsted, 440-455-1777, facebook.com/FIREDOUGHbakery

Gibbs Butcher and Brews

Why we love it: Born out of the long-standing Gibbs Butcher Block in Columbia Station, this restaurant brings the market’s reputation for fresh, local meats straight to the table. The menu leans into hearty, high-quality comfort food. Upstairs, Jimmy’s Place shifts the mood, channeling a 1930s speakeasy feel with a vintage bar, old-timey photographs, craft cocktails and seasonal jazz. Try this: The filet sliders ($24) feature tender beef medallions topped with lettuce, tomato and horseradish cream sauce, served with your choice of side. Go for the Amish baked beans, thick and rich with onions and bacon, delivering a sweet-and-savory bite that perfectly rounds out the plate. 8154 Columbia Road, Olmsted Falls, 440-793-6700, gibbsbutcherbrews.com 

Gunselman's Steakhouse & Bar

Why we love it: This scenic steakhouse delivers serious quality without the stiffness. The menu highlights premium cuts, including Hall of Fame Beef from Six Springs Farm, founded by former Browns player Joe Thomas. Downstairs, St. Kevin’s Kitchen keeps things relaxed with pub favorites, making it easy to move between elevated dining and comfort food in one destination. “We want to create a place the neighborhood can really be proud of,” says proprietor David Grace. Try this: The 73 ($110), a 12-ounce Full Blood Wagyu strip steak, features deep marbling that delivers a rich, savory bite. 7928 Main St., Olmsted Falls, 440-202-9705, gunselmanssteakhouse.com 

Imperial Garden

Why we love it: Bright and comfortable, the spacious dining room of the Chinese and Japanese restaurant pairs brown quilted leather chairs and soft blue-gray walls with subtle Asian-inspired details. A full bar with seating anchors the space, while the menu covers all the classics, from mei fun and lo mein to spring rolls and crab rangoon, along with a full sushi bar that rounds out the offerings. Try this: The General Tso’s chicken lunch special ($10.50) is served with steamed or fried rice and includes a choice of soup or egg roll. 24201 Lorain Road, North Olmsted, 440-471-4888, imperialgarden888.com  

Lee’s Seafood Boil

Why we love it: Seafood boils turn dinner into an experience, and that’s exactly the appeal here. Light wood floors, rows of roomy tables and warm overhead lighting that keeps the focus on relaxed, hands-on dining. Nautical touches like netting overhead and brick accents nod to the seafood theme, while the open layout makes it easy to accommodate groups and celebrations. Try this: The Handful ($37) offers a little bit of everything, piling together crawfish, head-on shrimp, andouille sausage, clams, corn and potatoes in one gloriously messy spread. Choose your sauce, from Juicy Cajun to garlic butter or the house blend, dial in the heat level, and dig in. 23642 Lorain Road, North Olmsted, 440-455-9003, leeseafoodboil.com 

Matteo’s

Why we love it: Tucked into the historic Grand Pacific Junction district, this long-standing Italian favorite strikes an easy balance between casual and special-occasion worthy. Wood floors, white tablecloths and rustic plank walls provide a warm, inviting feel. “The other partners and I all live in Olmsted Falls, and we have kids in the district, which I think is important,” says partner Jessica Cliff. “We’re focused on our community.” Dining unfolds across multiple rooms, from the welcoming front dining area to a lively back bar, while the menu leans classic with pastas, salads, antipasti, pizzas and hearty entrees. Try this: The Parmigiana ($28+) is notable for its savory marinara sauce, served over breaded chicken, eggplant or veal, topped with fresh tomatoes, ricotta and provolone, accompanied by spaghetti. 8072 Columbia Road, Olmsted Falls, 440-427-5400, matteoscleveland.com 

Moosehead Hoof & Ladder

Why we love it: Set inside a restored firehouse, this family-owned staple embraces its history with exposed brick walls, tin ceilings, stained-glass accents and original firehouse touches throughout. Burgundy tablecloths, warm wood finishes and ambient lighting give the dining rooms a cozy, lodge-like feel. Try this: The Moosehead baby back ribs ($23–$32) are a house signature, slathered in the restaurant’s special barbecue sauce and served with coleslaw and your choice of french fries or chips. 7989 Columbia Road, Olmsted Falls, 440-235-5511, mooseheadolmstedfalls.com

Ohashi

Why we love it: This neighborhood sushi spot is intimate, with a compact dining room and six-person sushi bar. Japanese-inspired artwork and wave-patterned wallpaper add subtle character to the relaxed space, while a surprisingly extensive menu offers more than 30 different rolls ranging from classic to playful. Try this: The Dragon Roll ($13.50) layers barbecue eel, avocado and glossy eel sauce over a California roll for a rich, savory bite that hits all the right notes. 24539 Lorain Road, North Olmsted, 440-716-0988, ohashi-sushi.restaurants-world.net 

Phnom Penh Restaurant 

Why we love it: Authentic Cambodian cooking delivers comfort, tradition and flavor at this low-key staple. The menu spans Cambodian and Southeast Asian classics, with noodle dishes, soups, curries and stir-fries offering some variety from the usual take-out scene. Try this: Kuy Teav Chha Kreoung Tek Trey Phoem ($17.49) is a vermicelli dish tossed with house-made kreoung, a fragrant Southeast Asian spice paste, chopped spring roll, sliced onion, lettuce, peanuts and coconut whip, all stir-fried into a layered, savory-sweet bowl. 27080 Lorain Road, North Olmsted, 216-251-0210, facebook.com/phnompenhres 

Parilya

Why we love it: Built on the success of its popular Filipino food truck, this family-owned spot opened a brick-and-mortar in 2023, giving Northeast Ohio a permanent place to enjoy its bold, comforting cooking. A Best of Cleveland pick in 2020, it delivers the same authentic flavors that made the truck a local favorite, now in a welcoming, sit-down setting. Try this: The Chicken Tocino ($17+) features pineapple-marinated chicken grilled on the flat top and caramelized with a house-made tocino pineapple glaze, finished with a fried egg. 8155 Columbia Road, Olmsted Falls, 440-427-5544, parilyacle.com 

Shibam Coffee Co.

Why we love it: Bright and elegant and luxe, Shibam brings a modern cafe experience with plenty of visual shine. The space glows with gold accents, geometric wall details and marble-style tables. A pastry case packed with treats steals the show, from baklava and sabaya, to soft, ultra-sweet milk cakes. Ordering is cafe-style; grab a buzzer, take a seat and soak it all in. Try this: The Spanish latte ($6.50+) is a standout, made with sweetened condensed milk for a rich, earthy flavor. Pair it with the caramel milk cake ($7), a moist, leche-style dessert that leans fully into dessert-lover territory. 26745 Brookpark Extension., North Olmsted, 440-385-7032, shibamcoffee.com

Sitoo’s 

Why we love it: Inspired by recipes shared around family tables, this quick-service Lebanese spot delivers balanced, casual and comforting Mediterranean favorites across multiple Cleveland-area locations. It turns a quick lunch into a warm, satisfying escape. Try this: The Sittoo’s Combo ($12.75) brings it all together, with shish kabob, kafta, chicken shawarma and falafel served alongside crisp salad, warm pita and cinnamon-sprinkled rice pilaf for a well-rounded, craveable plate. 24930 Lorain Road, North Olmsted, 440-716-8755, mysittoos.com

Travelers Grille

Why we love it: If you’re looking for a simple, hometown bar, this spot delivers. Traveler’s Grille leans into classic dive bar charm with blue walls, a pool table, darts and a patio that makes it easy to settle in. New owners Melissa Hatton and Steven Spencer took over in November and have since refreshed the interior, revamped the menu and built a more community-focused calendar with bingo nights and Friday karaoke. “We love to cook; we love to serve, and we thought this would be the perfect choice for us,” says Spencer, who is hands-on in the kitchen and prepares many of the featured dishes himself. Try this: The bacon barbecue wings ($8–$15) are a standout, tossed in a house-made sauce that’s sweet, smoky and loaded with chunky bacon that clings to every bite. 24532 Lorain Road, North Olmsted, 440-617-6848, facebook.com/TravelersGrille

For more updates about Cleveland, sign up for our Cleveland Magazine Daily newsletter, delivered to your inbox six times a week.

Cleveland Magazine is also available in print with immersive features, helpful guides and beautiful photography and design.