A Clevelander’s Guide to Ohio Amish Country: 35 Must-Go Spots

If you think you know the extent of Ohio’s Amish Country, you’re probably missing a city — maybe even a whole county. What you consider Amish Country could depend on a variety of factors: where you grew up, who you ask or what website you’re looking at.

Most sources agree that Ohio Amish Country’s densest populations span four counties. Two of them are clustered near central Ohio, and two are in Northeast Ohio.

There’s Middlefield in Geauga County, Trumbull County near Youngstown, and Tuscarawas and Holmes counties, which account for two of Ohio Amish Country's most popular hubs: Sugarcreek and Millersburg. Holmes County is the world’s second-largest Amish community, exceeded only by Lancaster County in Pennsylvania, one of the earliest Amish settlement spots in America.

All this to say, Ohio Amish Country is really big, and it would be impossible for someone to reasonably hit each of its regions in a short trip.

So, we’ve tailored a streamlined guide to Holmes and Tuscarawas counties exclusively, neighboring areas located about an hour and a half south of Cleveland. Our picks primarily fall within a 10- to 20-mile (or 10- to 30-minute) drive of each other, highlighting some smaller areas that are maybe not worth their own trip, but worth a stop while you’re in the area. 

Alley Cats Marketplace

More than 60 vendor spaces carry wares from a wide variety of local artisans. Shop year-round for selections that update seasonally. 115 Allen Lane SW, New Philadelphia, 330-340-6730, alleycatsmarketplace.com

Alpine Hills Museum

Explore centuries of Swiss and Amish history through artifacts and exhibits at this three-floor attraction conjoined with Sugarcreek’s Information Center. The building’s exterior stands out for its Swiss-inspired architecture and bright blue color. 106 W. Main St., Sugarcreek, 330-852-4113, alpinehillssugarcreek.com 

Amish Country Donuts & Cafe

This cozy space lives up to its name with locally roasted coffee, homemade doughnuts, pastries, breakfast sandwiches, salads and other meals. Situated quietly on the outskirts of downtown Sugarcreek, it’s the perfect location for spending a long morning or getting a quick afternoon fix. 522 Dover Road NE, Sugarcreek, 330-852-5214, amishcountrydonuts.com 

Andrea's Schnuck Store

Clothes, accessories, flags and other novelties cater to holidays, local sports teams and current fashion trends, providing a gift for everyone in the family. 4892 W. Main St., Berlin, 330-893-4135, andreasschnuckstore.com 

Bags Sports Pub

Even the country needs a sports bar, and this local hub delivers all the game-day vibes with familiar American fare, wooden furniture, vintage photos and plenty of TVs. 88 E. Jackson St., #A, Millersburg, 330-674-0279, facebook.com; 136 E. Main St., Sugarcreek, 330-852-3750, facebook.com

Baltic Mill Winery

This farmhouse-inspired space is warmed by wooden ceilings, fireplaces and leather couches, a perfect space for enjoying award-winning wines all year long. 111 E. Main St., Baltic, 330-365-0524, balticmillwinery.com 

bfearless.

Contemporary women’s fashion meets a rustic aesthetic at this countryside boutique. Find trendy wear for sports games, special occasions, cozy nights in and everything in between. The shop also offers consulting services with in-house stylists to help everyone find the clothes that fit them best. And just next door, bfearless. at HOME is a one-stop shop for decor, furnishings and kitchenware. 3147 State Route 39, Walnut Creek, 330-893-9201, b-fearless.com

Boyd and Wurthmann Restaurant

Enjoy a homestyle meal in a comfortable and familiar diner environment with booths, counter seating and a cash-only setup. Beyond a menu of carb-loaded plates, breakfast dishes and sandwiches, be sure to save room for a slice of homemade pie. 4819 E. Main St., Berlin, 330-893-4000, boydandwurthmann.com 

Breitenbach Wine Cellars

The colorful, castle-esque building is a retail space for more than a dozen wines, cheeses, meats and other winery snacks, plus a kitchen for a small food menu. The nearby vineyards produce sweet, fruity and dry blends, and a sprawling back patio overlooks some scenic farmland, where you might see a few cows or alpacas. 5934 Old Route 39 NW, Dover, 330-343-3603, breitenbachwine.com 

Broad Run Corner

This campus hits all the marks with Broad Run Cheesehouse, a retail cheese shop; Swiss Heritage Winery, a boutique vineyard; and Han’s Place, a restaurant for enjoying all the delicacies in a relaxed setting. 6011 Old Route 39 NW, Dover, no phone, broadruncheese.com 

Cafe Bistro and Lounge

This laid-back space is known for inventive shareables like creamy lobster bruschetta ($19) and fried Boursin cheese ($14), plus a menu of traditional entrees that’s highlighted by a variety of quality steaks. 104 Fair Ave. NE, New Philadelphia, 330-432-4488, craftbistroandlounge.com 

Collective Coffee Co.

This tri-roaster features a rotating selection of coffee beans from three businesses, in addition to energy drinks, teas and pastries. Though there are no tables for sitting, there’s ample room for shopping, as the cafe shares its space with a small boutique offering gifts, clothing, decor and jewelry. 113 S. Broadway St., Sugarcreek, no phone, instagram.com/collective.coffeeco 

Country Acres Mini Golf

The rustic, no-frills course is an exciting challenge with 36 holes of putt-putt fun. After your round, enjoy ice cream, kettle corn and other treats on the patio. 4367 State Route 39, Millersburg, 330-449-9986, countryacresminigolf.com 

Dola Jean’s Pizza

Experience Ohio Amish Country’s take on Detroit-style pizza, loaded with different sauces and toppings. Like its sister restaurant, Park Street Pizza in Sugarcreek, it's devoted to farm-to-table ingredients that change with the seasons. The L.A. Confidential ($19) is a unique favorite with white sauce, burrata, pistachios, prosciutto, arugula and a drizzle of apricot chile jam. 113 W. Third St., Dover, 330-346-3652, dolajeans.com 

Dundee Falls

Immerse yourself in Amish Country’s picturesque woods and hills with moderate hiking trails that culminate in awe-inspiring rock formations and waterfalls. 8525 Dundee Wilmot Road NW, Dundee

Dutchman Hospitality

One of Amish Country’s largest business groups presents several of the region’s favored tourist destinations, including Der Dutchman and Dutch Valley restaurants, offering buffet-style Amish comfort food; Dutch Valley Gifts and Carlisle Gifts, shopping hubs for an array of home decor, crafts and apparel; and Ohio Star Theater, a family-friendly venue bringing concerts, comedy shows, musicals and other entertainment to the country. Various locations, dhgroup.com 

East Main Kitchen & Coffee

Breakfast and lunch meals are inspired by some of the best-known comfort dishes, each remixed with the warm flavors of a backyard barbecue. 108 E. Main St., Baltic, 330-897-9065, eastmainkitchen.com 

Guggisberg Cheese

The Original Baby Swiss cheese was born here, but this factory and retail shop brings folks from states away for a unique selection of dozens of specialty cheeses, fudge, honey, syrups, jams and popcorn. 5060 State Route 557, Millersburg, 330-893-2500, babyswiss.com 

Hershberger's Farm and Bakery

This market, farm and pasture is the perfect destination for an all-in-one afternoon, home to an expansive gift shop, a scratch-made bakery, fresh produce, buggy and tractor rides, pumpkin patches, a petting zoo and concession stands. 5452 State Route 557, Millersburg, 330-674-6096, hershbergersfarmandbakery.com 

Hillcrest Orchard of Walnut Creek

This family-friendly spot is a go-to during the fall for its seasonal activities and scenic views. Peruse the farm market for fresh produce, baked goods, pumpkins, cider and other treats, or pick your own apples in the expansive fruit orchard. 2474 Township Road 444, Walnut Creek, 330-893-9906, cometowalnutcreekohio.com

Kauffman's Country Bakery

This bakery-cafe hybrid is one of Amish Country’s largest of its kind, serving its famous fruit cakes among breads, doughnuts, pies, fry cakes, cookies, paninis and an assortment of coffee beverages. 4357 U.S. 62, Millersburg, 330-893-2129, kauffmanscountrybakery.com 

Loose Caboose

This creamery and food stand offers walk-up service for both hard- and soft-serve ice cream, sundaes, milkshakes and a wide selection of hot dogs, sandwiches and fried appetizers. A small patio area adorned with string lights overlooks a real train caboose for vintage appeal. 122 Factory St. SE, Sugarcreek, 330-663-9249, facebook.com/LooseCaboose23 

Miller’s Creamery

Beyond small-batch ice cream and homemade caramel corn, this local staple is known for its scratch-made, soft-serve sherbet. The ever-growing list of flavors includes banana, strawberry, orange and blueberry, plus unique blends such as pink lemonade, green apple, Tropical Island and prickly pear. 2337 E. High Ave., New Philadelphia, 330-339-7555; 211 W. Third St., Dover, 330-364-4999, millerscreamery.com

Pleasant View Furniture

Decades of local craftsmanship pour into this curated showroom. See your dream space come together among wooden and upholstered furniture options, all made within the Amish community. 3599 U.S. 62, Dundee, 330-893-4322, pleasantviewfurniturellc.com 

Secret Garden

Enter a whimsical world of fairies, mushrooms, gnomes and botany among a jam-packed gift shop offering trinkets, plants and lawn decor. 4783 E. Main St., Berlin, 330-893-4466

Sheiyah Market

This market hall features dedicated shopping spaces for antiques, plants, furniture, decor and clothing, plus a coffee shop for a midday caffeine fix. Next door, the Berlin Antique Mall and Downtown Diner continue the experience. 4755 State Route 39, Berlin, 330-893-2648, sheiyahmarket.com

Sol’s 

This country store is Ohio’s largest craft mall; the vendor-style setup features candles, fabric, wall art, greeting cards, magnets and leather goods at reasonable prices. 4914 W. Main St., Berlin, 330-893-3134, solsinberlin.com 

Sugarcreek Village Inn

Those making their trip to Amish Country for an overnight stay can unwind in one of 17 rooms at this intimate lodging space that fuses nostalgia and modern design. Each room is renovated with updated amenities and located inside various old train cars for rustic flair. King- and queen-bed options make it an ideal experience for couples, small friend groups and solo travelers. 206 Factory St. SE, Sugarcreek, 330-852-9900, sugarcreekvillageinn.com 

The Mascot Syndicate

Behind the yellow door of this teal building in downtown Millersburg is a world of novelties and throwbacks, featuring vintage toys, colorful stationery, quirky gifts and nostalgic decor. 87 W. Jackson St., Millersburg, 330-473-8338, themascotsyndicate.com 

The Red Mug Coffee Co.

Roasting its own brand of beans, this shop prides itself on quality coffee beverages and a rotating pastry selection that’s made fresh every day. Stay through the afternoon and enjoy a hearty menu of breakfast and lunch dishes, too. 7789 County Road 77, Millersburg, 330-775-2880, theredmugcoffeecompany.com 

Toland-Herzig Famous Endings Museum

The idea for John Herzig’s exhibit was born from death. After receiving a program from boxer Joe Louis’ funeral, Herzig began collecting artifacts from the deaths and funerals of hundreds of famous people, including presidents, athletes and authors. It has amounted to more than 2,500 photographs, documents, audio recordings and other memorabilia. 803 N. Wooster Ave., Dover, 330-343-6132, tolandherzig.com/famous-endings-museum 

Troyer’s Sweet Shoppe

Treat your sweet tooth to a wide variety of chocolate candies, fudge, cookies and truffles. The family business has served Amish Country since the 1960s. 4 E. Jackson St., Millersburg, no phone, troyerssweetshoppe.com 

Victorian House Museum

The beautiful residence in Holmes County is included on the National Register of Historic Places, featuring 28 rooms across its 7,000 square feet. It was built in 1901 and designed by famous Cleveland architect Fenimore C. Bates. Exhibits and collectibles catalog the history of Holmes County and the 19th-century Victorian era. 484 Wooster Road, Millersburg, 330-674-0022, holmeshistory.com

Weaver’s Fine Furniture

Two expansive showrooms display Amish woodwork in upscale bed frames, vanities, dressers and dining tables, plus selections of home decor, mattresses and patio furniture. 7011 Old Route 39 NW, Sugarcreek, 330-852-2701, weaverfurniture.com

World’s Largest Cuckoo Clock

It’s not Big Ben, but it’s pretty big for its kind — nearly 24 feet tall, to be exact. The iconic tourist destination in Sugarcreek’s historic downtown chimes every half hour with a Swiss polka tune, and ceramic polka dancers emerge from the clock on a conveyor belt for a short routine. 100 N. Broadway St., Sugarcreek

As honorable mentions, we recommend these one-off Amish Country stops for your final destination when leaving town or your first stop when heading in.

63 Corks: 9185 U.S.- 250 NW, Strasburg, 330-878-4050, 63corks.com

Amish Door Village: 1210 Winesburg St., Wilmot, 330-359-5464, amishdoor.com 

Homestead Furniture: 8233 State Route 241, Mt. Hope, 866-674-4902, homesteadfurnitureonline.com 

READ MORE: Local Amish Furniture Maker Caught the Attention of The Metropolitan Museum of Art

Mohican Country Market: 1014 S. Market St., Loudonville, 419-994-1414, mohicancountrymarket.com 

Mohican State Park: 3116 State Route 3, Loudonville, 419-994-5125, ohiodnr.gov

Mrs. Yoder's Kitchen: 8101 State Route 241, Mt. Hope, 330-674-0922, mrsyoderskitchen.com

Ragon House: 10841 Fisher Road NW, Bolivar, no phone, ragonhouse.com

Experience More Local Getaways:

A Clevelander’s Guide to Kelleys Island: 31 Must-Go Spots

A Clevelander’s Guide to Oberlin: 22 Must-Go Spots

A Clevelander’s Guide to Canton: 21 Must-Go Spots

For more updates about Cleveland, sign up for our Cleveland Magazine Daily newsletter, delivered to your inbox six times a week.

Cleveland Magazine is also available in print, featuring immersive stories, helpful guides and beautiful photography and design.